I believe, on account of God’s revelation in the Bible, that He created Adam as the first human being, and that Adam and Eve were both very good. I believe that they were created in covenant with God as his children and regents upon the earth. Their task was to heed His warnings and fill the earth with His glory in perfect and perpetual obedience. They were created as able to sin or to obey, and by their own free choice, they disobeyed the law of God and became liable to death.
I do not believe that God’s law is an arbitrary standard. God could not have commanded evil to be good or good to be evil, because all divine commandments are derived from the unchanging character of God Himself. Therefore, every covenantal dispensation reveals the divine character and applies itself to those people in their particular time and place in redemptive history. Likewise, natural law is simply the revelation of the proscriptive will of God that is accessible to mankind in the revelation of creation by man’s intuition.
Therefore, Adam and Eve’s first transgression was utterly unreasonable, and searching out a sufficient cause for the first sin in their uncorrupted nature is impossible. They believed the unbelievable lie of Satan and truly deserved death and damnation.
Furthermore, since Adam was in a covenantal relationship with God, he stood as our covenant head. When he fell, he fell not only in himself but also as our representative. Therefore, all creation (he being the head of it), and all his descendants (he being their representative) also fell. On account of generation, we receive his corruption, and on account of imputation, we receive his guilt. Therefore, every human is conceived with the imputation of Adam’s guilt and condemnation as well as an inclination of the heart away from God and toward moral evil.
Because I believe that all mankind is born with an inclination to moral evil, I must distinguish how God holds all mankind - who are unable to keep His Law - to account. Man’s inability is a moral and evil inability, not an impossibility. It is possible, according to our human faculties of reason, speech, and movement to obey God, but our hearts are totally depraved. Even our apprehension of the divine will in natural law is corrupted by our moral rebellion. Therefore, God does not condemn a person on account of a physical handicap, but condemnation is always based upon moral rebellion.
In this way, I distance myself from both the Pelagian, Antinomian, and Hypercalvinist understandings of determinism and the judgment of God. Because we are at heart sinners at our inception, and the creation cannot obligate the Creator, Pelagianism must fall. Because God’s law proceeds from His perfectly excellent character, and requiring less would make God lesser, Antinomianism must fall. Because all mankind is duty-bound to obey God, and are held accountable for their denial of His revelation of Himself, Hypercalvinsism must fall.